Finding a Trustworthy Auto Repair Shop

Quick facts

  • Independent shops typically offer more parts options than dealership service departments.
  • The Better Business Bureau complaint history reveals more than star ratings on review sites.
  • Trying a shop with a minor service before committing to major repairs is a low-risk evaluation strategy.
  • Since the recession, most dealerships service all makes and models, not just their own brand.

Today's vehicles are automated and equipped with networks of computer-controlled systems. Most consumers find they are unable to repair or service their own vehicles, but finding a trusted repair facility can be daunting. Here are a few things to know when choosing the type of shop:

Independent shops can offer more personalized service by working directly with vehicle owners. They typically offer more choices in parts, and can recommend the best replacement parts.

Franchised/chain or auto dealers can be a good choice too, but keep in mind that since the recession, auto dealerships no longer work exclusively on the make of vehicle they sell, but all makes and models.

Referrals are the best way to find a good repair facility, so check with friends and family. If you are new to the area and don't have many contacts, check online for consumer referral organizations such as Angie's List and Car Talk.

Check the Better Business Bureau to see if the shop has a lot of complaints (or, more importantly, unresolved complaints). This reveals the ethics practiced by those who run the shop.

Don't wait until you need a major service or repair before trying a repair facility. Take your vehicle in for minor services such as an oil change or brake inspection. This will give you a feel for the shop, to see if their quality and service meets your expectations.

Next month's Insider will offer advice on what to look for and ask for when searching for a new repair facility.

Happy Motoring!

Frequently asked questions

Common questions

What is the practical difference between taking my car to a dealership versus an independent shop?

Dealerships have manufacturer-specific diagnostic software and training, which gives them an advantage on complex issues specific to that brand, including warranty work, software updates, and known technical service bulletins. Independent shops typically offer more flexibility on parts sourcing, more personalized customer relationships, and competitive labor rates. For routine maintenance and most repairs, a well-equipped independent shop with current diagnostic tools performs at the same level. The choice often comes down to the specific repair and your relationship with each facility.

How reliable are online reviews for evaluating auto repair shops?

Online reviews are useful as a starting point but should be read critically. A large volume of mostly positive reviews over several years is more meaningful than a handful of recent five-star ratings, which can be solicited. Look specifically at how the business responds to negative reviews. A shop that engages respectfully and resolves complaints demonstrates accountability. Reviews that mention specific technicians by name, describe the diagnosis process, or reference return visits tend to be the most trustworthy signals of consistent quality.

Schedule service

All About Automotive — 1850 NW Burnside Rd, Gresham, OR · (503) 465-2926

Ready to get started?

Book an appointment

Serving Gresham and the east Portland metro since 2000. Call us or book online and we'll confirm your time.